Why do doctors want Aamir Khan to apologize?

Besides the fact that they are corrupt, what is the one thing everyone hates about politicians?

It’s the fact that they are in a perpetual state of denial.

The economy might be falling to bits but they always have an explanation, which includes, pointing fingers at everything else except themselves.

There are bad apples in every profession. Why make anyone apologise for pointing it out?

So when I came across this bizarre page on Facebook where an umbrella body of 21 medical institutions are asking Aamir Khan to apologize for making everyone familiar with the various malevolent nitty-gritties of the medical profession, I was bemused. Doctors turning politicians is the last thing you will expect from someone with such impeccable intelligence. But then it isn’t so difficult, is it? You just have to be in denial.

I left a comment (in rather harsh words) on the main page of Medical Cases which has circulated this page on Facebook asking doctors to hit Aamir on Twitter.

Within minutes my comment was deleted and I was blocked from the page.

What I found profoundly sad and hilarious at the same time are the accusations. The doctors did not like the fact that Aamir displayed only one side of the coin.

I will call this poor observation power and what is ironical is the fact that this is coming from a community who earn its bread and butter by observing humans.

If anyone has followed the last five episodes of Satyamev Jayate, you will identify the pattern very easily – the programme always ends on hope. Without fail, there are always examples shown where people have fought back, where people have gone against the system and helped each other. The said episode about the malpractices in the medial stream was no exception.

The episode provided examples of Dr. Devi Prasad Shetty who helped poor farmers by covering them in an affordable insurance scheme so that they could go through expensive operation. The episode showed story of Dr. Shamit Sharma who helped patients to obtain generic medicines in Rajasthan at a much cheaper rate and Dr. Gulati who talked about the importance of the government pumping more money in health schemes.

It makes me extremely gloomy that a medical association of doctors who have a very high IQ and are much more intelligent than average humans chose to neglect all the positive aspects of their profession shown in the episode. They did not bother to thank Aamir for making people believe that there are still some good doctors in India.

Instead they chose to make Aamir apologies for showing something which every Indian already knows.

Let me iterate what the show has already underlined – there are good doctors and bad doctors. Stop anyone on the road and ask him and he can tell you a horror story about how he was manipulated and cheated by a doctor. But then you will also find people who will tell you about how they were saved by a very good doctor. There are doctors who work painstakingly towards the betterment of society.

Satyamev Jayate showed both the sides of the story. Why the Medial council chose to ignore the positive aspects is beyond me.

Maybe instead of asking Aamir to apologise, they should have asked all those doctors to apologies who kill unborn girls every day. Maybe they should ask all those doctors to apologize who are a part of organ trading. Maybe they should ask the Medical council of India to apologize for being aware of all the malpractices in the medical profession and still not terminating the licence of any of the doctors involved, thus playing with the life of millions of Indians.

A last piece of advice to Medical Cases - If you are circulating something on the internet, please do not except the whole world to agree with you. Everyone is entitled to their opinion and try to respect the opinion of someone who disagrees with yours.

Also, blocking someone does not make you right.

Act against the guilty. Don’t shoot the messenger.

About these ads

18 comments on “Why do doctors want Aamir Khan to apologize?

  1. Hi
    I am not a member of the Indian Medical Council and I have not made any money from this profession, and I am still in my medical training. What was presented by Amir hurt me personally. It is easy for you to say that it was not directed towards all the doctors. But no one talked about the millions of doctors working day and night to take care of their patients and also make their ends meet. I don’t think a non medical person has the capacity to understand the all the painstaking decisions a doctor needs to take. There is no one size fits all management for a problem, there is more than one way to take care of an medical issue and I don’t expect you to understand all these.
    I know a lot of people want to become doctors, but they soon realize that they don’t have the the dedication or mental capacity to become one. So to all those people like that don’t be jealous of us who have worked hard and still working hard to reach this position.
    If you see the comments, lot of people are writing that they don’t trust their doctors decision anymore after seeing the show. If a patient has a bad outcome because he did not trust what his doctor told him, Amir and people will be responsible for their medical complications faced by them.

    • Hi Anonymous,
      I understand what you are saying but the show did not paint all the doctors black. There were examples shown of doctors who have painstakingly worked with their patients. So when you say that “no one talked about the millions of doctors working day and night to take care of their patients and also make their ends meet”, you are basically wrong or haven’t seen the show properly.
      I think it’s quite OK not to trust a single doctor and take a second opinion. A lot of people do that. And it has been happening from years before the show aired and would have happened irrespective of the show.
      We all understand that doctors are humans and they make mistakes and sometimes things go wrong. The anger and frustration which comes is because no one likes to see a dear one hurt and not because of a show.

      You haven’t written anything about the malpractices prevelent in your profession. Do you believe they happen?

    • I know this is an age old post, and no one is going to read this, but then this fellow needs to be replied to….

      Look, my dear, you are young, and probably still have to go through the absurdly grueling post-grad entrance exams. So I will chalk your comment upto ignorance. If you actually believe what you have posted, the kind of abuse of the system rampant in the medical community will shock you. Haven’t you heard stories of IVF centers who harvest eggs once and implant it into multiple women (for non-medical people, when one has a “test-tube baby” they harvest ova, which are expensive to harvest and keep, and sperm, which are cheap. Telling women that her eggs have been harvested, while doing no such thing is unethical on so many levels). I could go on, and freely admit that these are just rumours I have heard from horrified gynecologists, but there is the case of hearing one too many rumours…. Apart from very few honourable exceptions, most doctors in (at least parts of North India I am familiar with) India have never heard of pubmed, haven’t cracked open a book since they graduated, and have learnt everything new from medical reps. Medical college infrastructure is in shambles, and all the faculty has roaring private practices. There is NO supervision over young trainees, in colleges where, as treatment is cheap, if not free, many of the poor in this country go for treatment. The private medical colleges, with there 1 crore donations, manage to teach the postgrads nothing. Gross medical negligence occurs about once a month, and nobody notices, and those who do notice go out of their way to hush things up.

      In times of depravity, the ones who shut their eyes to evil are as much at fault as those who commit evil. And on that basis alone, the entire medical community should hang their heads in shame.

  2. its ridiculous! why apologise for pointing out the harsh truth in the so-called noble profession of medicine?!
    I have had a horrible experience with doctors! its scarred me for life even though my folks have a great doc back home in Mysore and all their experiences re–instate your trust in doctors…
    And everyone I know has a bad tale to narrate abt doctors.

    • I guess they will be Ok after a while.
      Yes, as I said everyone have good and bad experiences with doctors. There was no need to be so touchy about that.

  3. Every community – social or professional or religious or caste or lingual – is touchy about themselves and these things are the outcome of that.

So, you were saying?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s